I have loved The Simpsons since their debut as shorts on The Tracey Ullman Show. That is how odd (and old) I am. We own all of the episodes available on DVD as well as all the books about the episodes. Obviously, even though all of these things are kept in the ‘grown-up movies’ cabinet, our children are privy to our enthusiasm for the show. Since he was 5, our son has begged to watch because it is, after all, a cartoon. We put him off with a simple “no” for awhile, but then felt the need to better explain why we felt it was not an appropriate show for kids (smart-mouthed, disrespectful youth and profoundly stupid adults was a main point - hugely hysterical for intelligent people, potentially ruinous for impressionable minds). And then we set a viewing age to stop the begging. Now he counts the days until he turns 10; in fact, he is planning a Simpsons party for that birthday. I’m a little chagrined in advance.
Previously, we had been able to avoid much handwringing about the injustice of not being allowed to watch a cartoon because our kids don’t watch commercial TV and knew very little about what they were missing. During the last year, however, the impending release of The Simpsons Movie has been unavoidable. From the gigantic Homer-hand holding a donut to the raucous previews in the theater, they have been keenly aware of its coming. And so are their friends - “When are you going to see The Simpsons movie?? I LOVE Bart! It’ll be so COOOOL!” Well. I am not a pushover mom - I’ve held my own against attempted invasions of Bratz and Xbox - but I’m starting to wonder about our ‘no see’ policy with the famous Springfield family. Despite many (intentionally) aggravating and embarrassing characterizations, the writing has consistently been smart, the storylines timely and thought-provoking. My son has come to understand that behaving like Calvin is not acceptable (emulating Hobbes would be far preferable; he’s getting there), and I could do much worse than have my daughter become a Lisa Simpson. So it might be time to lift the ban and see how well our parenting thus far holds up.
My husband & I saw the movie last night, along with a full theater at the Regal Broadway Metroplex (which charges only $6 for all movies, all the time and features comfy chairs and intermittent tables - go there!). It was a fantastic extended episode of the TV show. The only gimmicks employed for the big screen were fun jokes on the audience. As always, the writers take nothing seriously for more than a sentence. Even with a story centered around pollution, we are not made to feel overly guilty - it is, as usual in Springfield, an equal opportunity barrage of offenses. Essentially, most of the movie is what you get, content-wise, on Fox.
There are a few noticeable differences afforded with the PG-13 rating that are making me think hard about allowing my kids to watch it before the imposed age of 10. One is a mildly shocking but nonetheless outrageously funny (and thankfully brief) view of full frontal animated nudity. Another is an uncharacteristic but certainly well-deserved expletive from long-suffering Marge’s mouth. And Homer flips off the community at one point. If you are having any reservations about taking your children to see The Simpsons Movie, but would otherwise let them watch the show, these would be the only elements different from the TV episodes. The humor will often be over the heads of most kids (some it I’m still having to look up for better understanding), as will the typical sexual innuendo and political jabs. You will all, however, not be able to stop yourselves from singing the “Spiderpig” song over and over.
I will probably end up doing what I’ve done with the Spider-Man and Batman movies (because my son is intrinsically drawn to superheroes but still frightens easily with the bigger-than-our-house villains) - rent the DVD. It’s cheaper, we can easily skip parts if need be, and we get to know the people and effects behind the movie through special features, thus emphasizing the imaginative aspects and lessening the real lifeness. Because if my kid only takes away from this show the feeling that it’s okay to behave like a moron (which would be easy enough, for a 9-year old attention-seeker), I’ll truly deserve the Bad Mom badge. D’oh.